Opinions expressed by businessroundups.org contributors are their own.
One of your critical responsibilities as a CEO or General Manager is making the best decision for your company. While this is happening, there are times when your employees are bubbling with ideas that seem great to them, but may not be the best fit for the company’s growth. Reasons could be because of the current stage of the business or other factors.
Constructively rejecting employee suggestions is much more than just a typical human resource management job. One of the most helpful things you can do as a manager is to give employees feedback on why the suggestion might not be the best fit. Your ability to identify specific areas for improvement and motivate your team to take charge of their development will determine how well you can help employees move to the next level. And when you give your employees constructive criticism, it can inspire them to improve their performance and give them a better understanding of what they need to do to thrive in both their jobs and the company.
It can be challenging to reject an employee’s opinion because you want to maintain a happy and productive work atmosphere while still communicating your decision. Here are some suggestions for turning down an employee’s proposal without hurting their morale:
Related: How to Give Effective Feedback to Employees (and Why It Matters)
Table of Contents
1. Let them know you value their opinion
“Thanks for your suggestion, Michael. I’m not sure that’s the best move given the current financial state of the brand.”
Letting your employee know that you appreciate his involvement and thanking him for his suggestion, even if you can’t use his advice, shows that you value his opinion. This will encourage them to suggest something more beneficial next time. You also instill more confidence in them, and they can channel it to develop more suggested creative ideas when needed.
2. Provide clarity with respect
It is crucial to be truthful and explain why the company cannot fulfill the recommendation. Be careful not to give the employee the impression that his suggestion was inadequate or was rejected without thinking. Instead, explain and let them know you understand the suggestion. Be transparent so they understand why it can’t be hired. Make sure they are aware of the pros and cons of the recommendations.
Once you treat the suggestion with respect, they will be able to see through your message. They will be less critical if they feel that the proposal has been sufficiently thought through.
3. Provide early feedback
Suppose the proposed idea is meritorious, but cannot be implemented in this period; please consider providing suggestions on how it can be improved or changed in the future. Don’t just let them dangle. It’s normal to feel uncomfortable when you reject someone’s opinion. However, getting them to consider the suggestion bad is the worst thing you can do. If the answer has to be no, say so as soon as possible. This will help avoid doubts and fears on their part. They could also think about it better and come up with another working solution.
4. Suggest alternative approaches
There are occasions when the suggestion is okay; however, it should be more practical. In this case, consider offering different strategies or ways for the decision-making team to implement the employee’s concept into the work process. By bringing up another unique idea, they understand your approach and show that you appreciate their suggestion. They will also have a sense of involvement and want to be more committed to the growth of the company.
Related: Giving Creativity A Voice In The Workplace
5. Encourage them to develop the suggestion
A simple comment like “That sounds like a great idea. Could you elaborate?” can go a long way in helping your employees guide you through their thought processes. From there you may be able to get their angles and also know what can and can’t work. And if you have to decline the suggestion, the employees will understand that you care about their opinion. Meanwhile, as you ask them to elaborate, actively listen and try to understand from their point of view. Because if you show passive attention, the employee will notice and may feel offended.
6. Don’t be contemptuous or rude
While it’s important to be direct and honest when rejecting an idea, it’s just as crucial to be disagreeable or dismissive. You can kill employee morale, which can result in a poor work environment. It can also lead to a possible altercation or low self-esteem on the part of the employee. They would no longer feel safe to speak their mind where it matters. Being rude or dismissive will only damage their trust, create unhealthy competition, or cause ineffective devotion to duty. It would be ideal if you could avoid that.
7. Follow up with the employee
Consider reaching out to the employee to see if they have any new ideas or concerns after declining a suggestion. Doing this shows that you care about their suggestions and believe in their ideas as well. This shows your commitment to maintaining a supportive and productive work environment and your appreciation for their ideas.
Related: 8 Ways to Ensure Your Leadership Style Isn’t Offensive
Remember, it’s normal for people to take different viewpoints and approaches, and it’s okay to disagree. It is your responsibility to support the maintenance of a positive and effective work environment by treating things with respect and kindness. You can effectively decline an employee’s suggestion without hurting their morale if you use the tips in this article. It’s critical to be open and direct while expressing gratitude for employee engagement and inspiring them to keep contributing ideas.
